Charleston home inspector discusses deck safety.

Submitted by Ray Thornburg on Thu, 10/11/2012 - 08:07

A Charleston Home Inspector Discusses the most Common Deck Building Mistakes.

 

        Decks should be as safe as the rest of your home. Below is a general discussion of the most common problems we find. It is not intended to be a recommendation or specific remedy for any particular situation. At Blue Palmetto Home Inspection we want you to be safe!

 

Cost driven- This is when the avoidance of extra spending drove the decisions to build and design the deck in an substandard way.

Improper Foundation- Although inspectors do not have x ray vision proper pier support is essential to weight distribution and is the fundamental reason for deck sag.

Beams not sufficient- Most of the time load bearing support beams need to be doubled up to carry the weight between supports.

Undersized Joists- We see many decks with joists that either exceed the span rating or are undersized for the application. Sometimes the spacing between joists is excessive for the application.

Improper beam support- Most of the time 50% of the beam thickness needs to be supported by a post. Where sills or girders are used at least 1.5 inches bearing on wood (3" for concrete) is required. Bolting a girder to the sides of the post without any other support is improper. Where bolts are used like this there should be at least two 1/2" through bolts per connection.

Improper attachment to structure or at structure- If the structure is used to support part of the deck then lag bolts or in some situations special fasteners that cannot be subject to withdrawal should be used.

Improper fasteners- Treated wood can be corrosive. Deck screws are good for holding the decking to the structure but because shear strength issues they should not be relied upon to attach joist hangers (unless specifically designed) or for structural sections of the deck. Make sure the fastener is designed for decks and is corrosion resistant.

Flashing- Decks should be properly flashed where they are attached to the house. They should be flashed behind and on top with proper flashing, Do not use aluminum with treated wood. Use PVC type so it won't rust through.

Age- Sometimes they just get old....You can expect the walking surface deck boards to last about 20-25 years, substructure will last longer so sometime you can breath new life into a old deck by replacing the decking. Handrails get old, fasteners rust, things happen.

Handrails and Guardrails- Sometimes they're the wrong height or the spacing between pickets is too great. Sometimes they are flimsy. Our stairway requirement page has more information on handrails.

No graspable handrail- Newer codes require a continuous graspable handrail on steps.

Steps substandard- No center stringer, open risers, unequal risers or treads, improper support or sloped treads are among the problems here.

Attachment to masonry or brick veneer- Attachment to masonry for support has to be part of an engineered design. Brick veneer is not designed to support decks.

Building deck level with interior finish floor- You can do this.....but it'll be hard to keep the water out. It's best to have a slight step down so water won't be tempted to slide in under the door. There's also the splash back issue. Water hitting the deck splashes back onto door jambs and seeps into cracks causing moisture damage. A small step down helps mitigate this issue.

Post size too small- Let's face it.... 6x6's are expensive....more expensive than 4x4's ....and heavy. Maybe that's why so many tall decks are built with 4x4's. Anything over 8' needs to be 6x6. If 4x4's are used they need to be reinforced every 8'.  

 

 

General Rules for Building a Safe Deck

·      Decks need to be positively anchored to the main structure (unless independently supported) with fasteners like 1/2'” lag screws that cannot back out easily.

·      Lags should be staggered and installed 2” from top and bottom of ledger spaced according to the designed load.

·      Girders supporting other joist should not be supported only on the deck ledger (the ledger is the board that is attached to the home) unless specifically designed. Ledgers shall not be supported by or on stone or brick veneer.

·      Newer codes (2009 and later)  require 2 tension hold down devices per deck. This is a type of device which is attached to the interior floor joist and exterior floor joist and connected by a threaded rod. This will help keep the deck from separating from the structure in case something crazy happens.

·      Bottom of footings or piers need to be at least 12” below ground level, below the frost line and at least four inches bigger all around than the post that sits on it.  Wider pier will support more weight and we like to see it at least 8” thick.  Of course this recommendation will change according to local soil conditions and codes or actual engineered analysis. Must be able to support the load imposed.

·      Decks need to be designed to support 40 lbs per sq ft live load minimum or more if a special load is imposed (like a hot tub).

·      Columns should be restrained to resist lateral displacement at the bottom end and uplift forces.

·      Columns should be treated to prevent rot except when they are supported by a metal pedestal 1” above concrete and 6” above the ground.

·      Columns not less than 4x4.

·      Positive connections required to prevent uplift. (i.e. high wind event)

·      The end of each joist, beam or girder shall have at least 1 ½” bearing on wood or metal. They can also bear on 2x2 ledger strips or approved joist hangers.  A 1x4 ribbon strip is also allowed if attached to adjacent stud.

·      Joist need to be supported laterally at the ends by blocking or rim joist.

·      Guards (approved handrails) shall be provided for any walking surface more than 30” above grade. Should be at least 36” high.

·      Guards and handrails must not be flimsy. (must resist 200 lb force)

·      Steps must withstand a 300 lb point load on any 4” square.

·      Pickets no more than 4” apart except step pickets which should be 4 3/8” apart.

Other Important Rules

·      Flashing should be above, behind and below the ledger.  Do not use aluminum flashing as it will corrode. Use PVC flashing types with the newer treated wood.

·      Use deck screws or spiral hot dipped galvanized nails on decking walking surface and you won’t get nail pops.

·      Use proper fasteners. Most of the time deck screws are not designed to be used for structural parts like beams and joist hangers because of shear strength issues.  They are hard and brittle and snap under stress. Use joist hanger nails for joist hangers and paslode nails are a good choice for structural parts. They’re a variety of fasteners and hangers available so read the package to make sure it’s the correct ones. Even stainless steel comes in different grades so check for proper application.

In my opinion rang shank fasteners are fine for applications where withdral might occur (like decking boards or sheathing) but should be advoided in areas where structural strength is a concern (like nailing beams, joists together). This is based on my observations at the ease in which they can be snapped in half compared with other nail types. I've noticed that when a rang shank nail starts to bend,  it often just snaps in half. I'm waiting for engineering proof to catch up with my observations however.

·      Do not attach ledgers to I-trusses or the top 2x4 of web type floor trusses.

·      Space decking boards about the thickness of a penny to account for swelling and contraction.

About Pressure Treated Wood

Wood decay can occur from fungus or termites or other wood destroying organisms. So it's required that wood which can resist decay be used outdoors. Typically this involves using pressure treated wood. Be advised though that the pressure treated wood available today is not the same as it was years ago. You might be disappointed in it's performance. So we recommend field treating ends of posts with a preservative like copper naphththenate. It is also wise to treat decking boards with it every so often. The amount of protection of any brushed on protectant is dependant on its penetration so use plenty for best results. Be sure to use wood rated for ground contacted especially if it's in or on the ground. There are tags on the ends of the boards with the rating.

As a personal note many years ago pressure treated wood was really reliable from my personal experience with working with it. The chemicals they use to treat wood with appear to be less effective now.  I've seen lumber, even lumber which is traditionally ground contact rated,  less than ten years old decay from fungus so much as to render it useless. I have also seen this in treated lumber used above ground which only occaionally recieves moisture penetration. I consider this type of performance so dismal as to rival untreated wood. As a consumer we are limited by the products available at the local lumber yard so it appears that the days of a worry free exterior wood deck or porch may be a thing of the past. I imagine that there may be structural collapses caused by this in the near future. So monitoring is recommended for any exterior deck. Be advised. As always we welcome any comments about this in the discussion box below.

 

·      References 2003 IRC 502.2.1, 2006 IRC 502.2.2,2009 IRC 502.2.2.1.1, 2006 IRC 502.2.2.2, IRC R403, 403.1.4. IRC R 407.3. IRC R319.1, IRC 502.9, IRC 502.6, IRC 502.9

 

Now Lets look at some pretty pictures taken while doing home inspections in the Charleston area.

 

proper deck flashing detail

     I drew this exploded view to show the proper deck flashing detail.  Click image to enlarge. Notice the three piece flashing is preferred but flashing piece # 3 could be eliminated and # 2 and # 1 could be formed in one piece and it would still work. Flashing # 3 if installed will help keep leaves and debris from forcing its way between the deck ledger and the flashing (it acts as a wedge) compromising connective strength over time. One trick I used to use is to fill that area between the first decking board and the house with clear silicone. Not to divert moisture but to keep debris out of that joint. Makes for easier maintenance and a cleaner appearance. Not shown in the drawing is the house wrap. It is important to note that house wrap is not flashing. House wrap  serves as an air barrier to improve energy efficiency. It has a tendency to divert liquid water away from the structure but is actually designed to allow water vapor in the air to pass through to help keep wall cavities dry. It should be lapped correctly in any case. The picture assumes wood sheathing is used. 

 

bad flashing at deck The picture at left shows damage from an improper flashing method. The flashing was bent at a 90 under the deck board. The salt in the deck board quickly rusted out the galvanized flashing on this 10 year old home (blue arrow).  It allowed moisture penetration (red arrow) thus causing rot and finally termites were attracted to it (yellow arrow). The yellow arrow shows termite tracking tubes. The house had to be gutted to fix the termite damage. The newer types of treated wood has a higher salt content so PVC flashing should be used. Aluminum or galvanized metal will rust quickly. Finally the flashing should totally separate the deck from the house and hang down below the sheathing an inch to prevent wicking. As the picture to the left shows the only separation this deck had was house wrap with is not adequate.

 

 

flashing to high The picture at left shows how the flashing was flush to the osb sheathing and drip back  and wicking is rotting the sheathing at that location. This common deficiency could have been easily avoided simply by dropping the flashing down about an inch.

 

 

 

 

 

proper post to beam connection

 

This is the proper way to install a post and beam. This photo courtesy of internachi. Beam is fully setting on post and it has two bolts going through it. Beams, joists, girders are required to have at least 1.5 inches bearing on the wood unless a metal connector is used. Reference  IRC 2012 R502.6.

 

 

 

 

single member deck joist

   

 

     In this picture we see a lot of good intentions but it misses the mark. Single band joist attached to side of post with no only one through bolt into undersized post. The angle braces do help a little to transfer the load but isn't a substitute proper design. All is not lost though there are several inexpensive ways to fix this which would satisfy the intent of the code.

 

 

 

 

options for improving deck support    We see a lot of marginally supported decks; some are built with a single band joist, sometimes with no joist hangers or through bolts. Decks with single band joists are very likely under supported. Picture at left shows some options for improvement. Depending on your situation it may be possible to drop a 2x in under the existing single band joist (B under A). (C) can be added for joist end support on the inside or can be slid over (blue arrow) to double up (B). A ledger can be added (D) or through bolts used. If a ledger is used like this it should be at least 24" long (or it can run the whole length of post to strengthen it too). The size of (B or C) will depend on the load and the distance between supports. Some newer prescriptive rules for band board support (like A) do not allow support even with two through bolts so would require a ledger (like D) in the illustration.

 

 

 

 

 

 

stair rail spacing

 

Picture shows the maximum spacing between pickets on a stairway.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

deck with no center stringer

    Obviously a good example of how not to build the steps on a deck. No center stringer, open risers, and a huge gap beside the wall big enough to drive a truck through. They did try to put a grippable handrail up against the wall but it's so close you cant get your fingers around it.

 

 

 

 

 

rotted sill

     Here's a pic of the same deck. The deck is independently supported.... see the posts next to the wall;  to avoid lagging it through the wall. That didn't stop the damage though. Splash back caused the damage you see in the photo. Flashing under the door may have prevented this damage. A storm door may have helped also.

 

deck fastener spacing

 

Pictures shows the proper placement of lag bolts when used to hold deck ledger to house.

 

 

 

old charleston gazebo   

Here is an old gazebo built in a Charleston backyard. This is a good example of why lattice shouldn't be used as a handrail - guard. It's flimsy, and doesn't age well. Guards have to be able to withstand a 200 lb force. Looks like this deck has seen better days huh. Time to start over.

 

no flashing between house and deck     This deck must have been added after initial construction. There is no flashing between the house and the deck. Corner boards already shows signs of decay. Even though fiber cement board is rot resistant vapor drive through the house wrap will eventually result in decay of underlying structural elements.

 

 

Deck attached to brick veneer.     There really is no good way to attach a deck to brick veneer. Many times we see decks like this with only cut nails holding the deck to the brick. Cut nails are brittle and not suitable for loads. Recipe for disaster. This deck should be independently supported.

 

 

improper supported deck in charleston     In this picture the deck is improperly supported up against the house by nails only through fiber cement siding. Further examination revealed that osb I trusses were used in the house floor system. Let's do the math- 3" nail - 1.5" band joist-1/2" fiber cement- 1/2 sheathing = 1/2" left over which in this case has penetrated into nothing but an air space. Fiber cement siding offers no structural support. This deck should be independently supported.

 

 

improper deck support method     At left is a picture of how not to connect a deck to a house. This is similar to what is happening in the picture above. As you see fasteners of any length would not offer sufficient support here. Even if the siding was removed at this location it would still be insufficient. The same hazard exists when web type trusses are used. In this case the deck should be supported independently of the home.

 

 

 

 

 

deck tension hold down device    Newer rules require a deck tension hold down device like the one shown at left made by simpson. Essentially a threaded rod is used to attach two specially designed ties nailed at 90° angles. This will keep the deck from pulling away from the house in cases where the attachment was only to the rim joist. I'm citing fair use to the use of their image for educational purposes. They make several different types of hold down devices for different application needs.

Submitted by Ray Thornburg on Thu, 10/11/2012 - 08:07

Comments

Anonymous | Tue, 02/19/2019 - 15:14

Can I use deck foundation blocks inset of concrete footing for a ground level deck. Charleskinnear@yahoo.com

Ray Thornburg | Wed, 02/20/2019 - 09:19

Requirements for a footing varies depending on your location and load requirements.  You want the bottom of the footing to be below frost level to prevent frost heave. Also there's the question of uplift resistance. A block sitting on grade has none. If you live in an area where the frost level is at grade more or less then the blocks would likely still not be sufficient unless the porch was just a simple small stoop that you don't mind tearing down and redoing in few years. If you do it, do it right because you'll find out you might have to live with that "temporary" thing for a long long time.  If you dig a footing for the posts make sure the bottom of the trench is level, and make it about 16" square and pour in about 8 inches of concrete and embed a strap to connect the post. Having a footing which is larger than the post distributes the weight better and it makes it easier to square up your deck and place the posts. After the posts are set and the deck is properly supported you can add more concrete at the post bottoms help to prevent lateral displacement if desired. This assumes average soil load bearing capability (marshy areas can be problematic). If your deck is elevated, on a mountain side, or has unsual loading requirments or is only supported by several columns then special consideration or engineering may be necessary.

Anonymous | Fri, 09/01/2017 - 06:39

I just spoke to Ray about a correction to my deck. He was VERY friendly and helpful, and saved me LOTS of time and money.

Ray, thank you for being so helpful, and for putting this website together. God bless you!

Bob from Roanoke, VA

Anonymous | Tue, 10/16/2012 - 19:52

Hi! www.summerville-home-inspector.com admin, i love to read your site
Kredyt hipoteczny